Post

Vivolkha wrote:

To put it simply, the nominee is worthy, but the resolution probably not. I wonder if it could've been written in a better way.

It would be hard to do so, and in my opinion this resolution can't really be written in a way that I'd support. N-G has made a huge contribution to the site, but the Dark Theme is considered non-admissible per SC rules as something that is similar to a "staff contribution". Some people argue it's unfair to exclude it, but ultimately the mod created rules are the rules to some extent, and I'm a bit wary about voting for this because of the dangling "well they did do the Dark Theme" argument.

I will say, of all WA resolutions, this is not one where I'm particularly strong-willed. I'm pretty set in my convictions and happy to talk about it, but no judgement or larger disagreement rests with those who disagree with me--reasonable minds can disagree on this and that's OK