by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Advertisement

Search

Search

[+] Advanced...

Author:

Region:

Sort:

«12. . .6,1696,1706,1716,1726,1736,1746,175. . .28,41728,418»

The seventh reich of germany

Kraljevstvo rata wrote:Still failing to answer the world's most ancient question. Why? or even How?

this is a alt history where Germany was super smart and built up their military while gaining many allies and won both wars including the german-french war and ww1.

The seventh reich of germany wrote:this is a alt history where Germany was super smart and built up their military while gaining many allies and won both wars including the german-french war and ww1.

Uh, right, cause RL Germany was definitely lacking in the land army department.

Also, how would the Ottomans suppress French revolts? The Ottomans are even MORE unstable.

Finally, not EVERY nation wants land. Austria-Hungary sure as hell didn’t. Switzerland doesn’t. San Marino? No. Monaco? No. Australia? No.

Kraljevstvo rata

Kraljevstvo rata

The seventh reich of germany wrote:this is a alt history where Germany was super smart and built up their military while gaining many allies and won both wars including the german-french war and ww1.

germany was already enjoying a pretty large army. but, if that's your alt history, i guess that's it. Just fix the plot holes, please? make it more realistic as well.

Mand islasce wrote:Hello everyone

Guten Tag

Kraljevstvo rata and Mand islasce

South Acren

Keep it German and war free for 24 hours. You're in charge. With no actual powers or anything.

K byyyyeeeee

Hoffania, Kraljevstvo rata, and Thepeopl

Kraljevstvo rata

I express my dissatisfaction with Kyorgia.

The seventh reich of germany

Kraljevstvo rata wrote:germany was already enjoying a pretty large army. but, if that's your alt history, i guess that's it. Just fix the plot holes, please? make it more realistic as well.

The Germans also had many competent allies except Italy and the ottomans of course

Minskiev wrote:Uh, right, cause RL Germany was definitely lacking in the land army department.

Also, how would the Ottomans suppress French revolts? The Ottomans are even MORE unstable.

Finally, not EVERY nation wants land. Austria-Hungary sure as hell didn’t. Switzerland doesn’t. San Marino? No. Monaco? No. Australia? No.

san marino and Monaco aren't important Switzerland is neutral and Austria is dead and Australia didn't get involved to get more land they got involved to prevent Germany and the rest of the central power from becoming even more powerful and the ottomans got Egypt nothing more.

The seventh reich of germany wrote:The Germans also had many competent allies except Italy and the ottomans of course
san marino and Monaco aren't important Switzerland is neutral and Austria is dead and Australia didn't get involved to get more land they got involved to prevent Germany and the rest of the central power from becoming even more powerful and the ottomans got Egypt nothing more.

Uh, so? You said every nation wants land, and I gave you a list of nations who don’t want land. You can’t refute that, it’s a fact that they don’t want land. Doesn’t matter if they’re dead.

Also, WHAT competent allies? The German Empire had no competent ally other than Bulgaria, and they were too small to do much.

The seventh reich of germany

Minskiev wrote:Uh, so? You said every nation wants land, and I gave you a list of nations who don’t want land. You can’t refute that, it’s a fact that they don’t want land. Doesn’t matter if they’re dead.

Also, WHAT competent allies? The German Empire had no competent ally other than Bulgaria, and they were too small to do much.

Romania wasn't to bad plus the only country you specified on there was in a defensive war

The seventh reich of germany wrote:Romania wasn't to bad

Romania was not a German ally in WW1. I specifically said German Empire, not German Reich.

Also, you realize the Franco-Prussian War wasn’t a world war, right?

The seventh reich of germany

Minskiev wrote:Romania was not a German ally in WW1. I specifically said German Empire, not German Reich.

Also, you realize the Franco-Prussian War wasn’t a world war, right?

I never said it was a world war plus we weren't Prussia we bribed Romania into the central powers by giving the Transylvania. We were the German empire and it was the central powers versus Britain and France so not a world war actually read my history instead of skimming over it.

The seventh reich of germany wrote:I never said it was a world war plus we weren't Prussia we bribed Romania into the central powers by giving the Transylvania. We were the German empire and it was the central powers versus Britain and France so not a world war actually read my history instead of skimming over it.

Well, you didn’t mention that in your lore. Also, if it was the CP versus the Entente, why was only France and Russia fighting at the beginning? Where was the US, or the UK?

The seventh reich of germany

Minskiev wrote:Well, you didn’t mention that in your lore. Also, if it was the CP versus the Entente, why was only France and Russia fighting at the beginning? Where was the US, or the UK?

Russia wasn't involved as they were goin through the revolution and I did mention what land I gave to each country in my factbook and the Zimmerman telegram never happened so the us never got involved and the UK was reluctant seeing the size of the central powers and later joined but it was to late.

The seventh reich of germany wrote:Russia wasn't involved as they were goin through the revolution and I did mention what land I gave to each country in my factbook and the Zimmerman telegram never happened so the us never got involved and the UK was reluctant seeing the size of the central powers and later joined but it was to late.

Your ability to fix plot holes and create more with godmodded on-the-spot lore is just comical, at this point.

First off, the whole reason Lenin’s movement gained traction was because of the deplorable conditions of war. Also, Russia was incredibly weak. They would never have been successful without Russia being in WW1 and getting whooped so badly.

Second off, the Zimmermann telegram was sent knowing that the US would go to war, even without its discovery, as Germany was ready to ramp up submarine warfare. So not sending the Zimmermann telegram is just taking away chances of German Allies.

Third off, what do you mean size of the Central Powers? Look at a map comparing Central Powers and Entente. Honestly that just sums up my point.

The seventh reich of germany

Minskiev wrote:Your ability to fix plot holes and create more with godmodded on-the-spot lore is just comical, at this point.

First off, the whole reason Lenin’s movement gained traction was because of the deplorable conditions of war. Also, Russia was incredibly weak. They would never have been successful without Russia being in WW1 and getting whooped so badly.

Second off, the Zimmermann telegram was sent knowing that the US would go to war, even without its discovery, as Germany was ready to ramp up submarine warfare. So not sending the Zimmermann telegram is just taking away chances of German Allies.

Third off, what do you mean size of the Central Powers? Look at a map comparing Central Powers and Entente. Honestly that just sums up my point.

The central power gained a lot of people after Austria Hungary and I'm explaining how things work and that automatically god modding plus only two countries of the entente were involved plus Lenin was to start a small doomed revolution to distract russia but people liked his idealism so the revolution was successful and besides I'm not explaining it on the spot I'm telling you all the stuff I didn't put in because I don't want it to long as it's already going to be large after I'm done with the timeline.

The seventh reich of germany wrote:The central power gained a lot of people after Austria Hungary and I'm explaining how things work and that automatically god modding plus only two countries of the entente were involved plus Lenin was to start a small doomed revolution to distract russia but people liked his idealism so the revolution was successful and besides I'm not explaining it on the spot I'm telling you all the stuff I didn't put in because I don't want it to long as it's already going to be large after I'm done with the timeline.

If you didn’t put it in, it seems like you put it on the spot. And you saying you didn’t isn’t evidence enough to prove that you didn’t.

Also, you really think Russia wouldn’t have crushed the Revolution? They were the third strongest nation at the time, and the only reason the Revolution was successful was because of Germany weakening Russia.

The seventh reich of germany

I'm tired arguing with idiots who think they know everything and that everyone has to do everything their way.

The seventh reich of germany wrote:I'm tired arguing with idiots who think they know everything and that everyone has to do everything their way.

I’m tired of arguing with an idiot who knows about as much about geopolitics and the history of war as they know about grammar.

Kraljevstvo rata and Aandruzognivia

Idiots have rights. End discrimination now!

Hoffania, Kraljevstvo rata, and Aandruzognivia

Warzone Codger wrote:Idiots have rights. End discrimination now!

The right to remain silent ;D

The seventh reich of germany

Minskiev wrote:I’m tired of arguing with an idiot who knows about as much about geopolitics and the history of war as they know about grammar.

I know plenty about history and how does geopolitics affect my alt history

The seventh reich of germany wrote:I know plenty about history and how does geopolitics affect my alt history

Uh, you know, diplomacy?

A Leaf on the Wind wrote:South Acren

Keep it German and war free for 24 hours. You're in charge. With no actual powers or anything.

K byyyyeeeee

Would you rather massage or be massaged?
Would you rather cook or eat?
Would you rather sport yourself or watch?

I am the "active" person, would choose the active option 75% of the time.

Today is the 3d day of walking. "10k". 5 children and 2 adults are "exploring" the neighbourhood. Trying to find nice spots where we haven't been before. Yesterday we saw awesome graffiti and had lunch in a "care farm" (a place where disabled people work. They tend the gardens, the animals, the kitchen etc. Don't expect fast service and you'll have a very enjoyable experience). I had a goat cheese/ grilled vegetables/ beetroot spread club sandwich.

Today we'll start with the car and walk 12k across several city parks. (12 k = 7.45 miles)

We had planned to walk the 30 k with our 11 year old as a participant in the "Nijmegese Vierdaagse". But alas Social Distancing made it impossible. Maybe next year.

Warzone Codger, Hoffania, and Kraljevstvo rata

Ancient republics

Warzone Codger wrote:Idiots have rights. End discrimination now!

We already let them vote, what else do you want from us?!

Warzone Codger, Kraljevstvo rata, Aandruzognivia, and Thepeopl

Refrigerator resurrection

Ancient republics wrote:We already let them vote, what else do you want from us?!

Letting idiots vote ("idiot" should be formally defined, because one could brand one's intelligent political opponents "idiots"...) could be valuable because even idiots have needs they should make known, but then again you don't want them getting together because of idiot-pleasing arguments to throw their considerable weight behind the next dictator.

Warzone Codger, Hoffania, Kraljevstvo rata, and Aandruzognivia

«12. . .6,1696,1706,1716,1726,1736,1746,175. . .28,41728,418»

Advertisement